Paper Coffee Cups vs Plastic Cups: Which Is Better for Business?
Whether it’s takeaway or dine-in, starting the day with morning coffee is quite popular in Canada. There are several coffee chains and independent cafes that serve regular or specialty drinks. Some use paper cups, and others use plastic ones. But the debate still goes on about choosing paper or plastic for their business. They have to juggle things like cost comparison and eco-friendliness. Ceramic or glass is often considered the safest option in terms of environmental impact, but they are not generally suitable for food truck businesses or takeaways.
Plastic or paper cups are single-use disposable cups usually suitable for catering services and on-the-go coffee runs. They can be very efficiently used as marketing tools for businesses featuring printed or embedded logos and brand names.
Most people hear “paper” and instantly assume that it is better than plastic. But if a deep structural analysis is conducted, the reality can be a little different. Both have benefits and drawbacks of their own. They are disposable and can be recycled. However, one has to be aware and considerate of the recycling method for both cups.
What are Paper Coffee Cups?
Paper cups are made from food-safe materials that are lined with PE to prevent leaks and tears. These coffee cups can be used for hot or cold beverages. They often seem eco-friendly and reflect quality. Paper cups can enhance appearance and brand perception.
Paper coffee cups are available in different sizes and structures. Each one of them varies in its insulation design and cost. They are classified as:
- Single-wall paper coffee cups
- Double-wall paper cups
- Ripple wall paper cups
What are Plastic Cups?
These types of cups are highly durable in their structure. Plastic cups are crystal clear in appearance and most commonly used for cold brews or chilled smoothies. They are lightweight and are easy to stack. The following materials are used for manufacturing:
- Polystyrene
- Polyethylene Terephthalate
- Polypropylene
Insulation: Paper vs. Plastic Cups
Paper coffee cups usually have better thermal insulation due to their walled structures for ripple or corrugated cups, or added paper sleeves with single-wall cups. The rippled structure creates a gap between the inner and outer layers, which ultimately slows heat transfer. Plastic cups, on the other hand, have poor insulating properties as compared to paper cups. They are preferred for cold drinks or juices. An extra plastic cup might be required as cups start sweating due to very cold drinks. If they are exposed to very hot drinks, they might start deforming or release harmful chemicals like styrene or BPA.
But there are factors as well that can affect the heat retention in both cups. These are:
- If the cups are covered with lids
- Size of the cups
- Exterior temperature or atmosphere
- Consumption time for the drink
- Actual temperature of the beverage
Cost analysis
Plastic cups appear more cost-efficient as they have fewer manufacturing steps compared to paper cups. They don’t require additional coatings or linings to prevent leaks. Their lightweight structure reduces costs during shipping and transportation of large volumes.
Now, if we analyze the manufacturing and printing costs for paper cups, they have a higher cost per unit. Paper coffee cups have hidden costs. The two-layered structure adds manufacturing steps and labour costs. Other than this, inner linings and coatings are necessary to prevent liquid and heat retention. Also, if the cups are single-walled, an added paper sleeve can increase per-unit cost. They have hidden costs as well, such as shipping and waste disposal.
Sustainability Concerns
Paper and plastic are not generally environmentally friendly. They are recyclable but still dependent on waste management infrastructure. If the industry is not equipped with recycling machinery, it’ll eventually end up in landfills. Even biodegradable options need commercial-level composting. Plastic cups are not biodegradable and end up in landfills, leading to microplastics.
Which cup is better for your business?
Choose Paper Coffee Cups if:
- You serve hot drinks or beverages.
- You prefer high brand value
- You want a smooth surface for Visual printing
- Your municipality accepts the type of paper cups you use
- Your cups are commercially accepted in standard recycling streams
Choose Plastic Cups if:
- You serve cold drinks or layered boba teas
- You value product display and visibility
- You have a low budget
- You have less storage space
- Your area has very humid weather
- You are adding toppings with dome lids
Conclusion
You can select any of the cups for serving, but a sustainable option comes with paper cups only. A business that serves different beverages can opt for either of the two options based on the temperature. However, a sustainable option is always a paper-based cup due to its recyclable nature. Brands can select various options of paper cups from Custom Grease Papers. A brands that manufacturer premium quality cup at affordable rates.
